Arch Manning Could Be Leaving Millions on the Table as Texas Star Teammate Calls Longhorns “Naive” to NIL
*April 21, 2025 – Austin, Texas | By College Football Insider*
In a revelation that has sparked debate across the college football world, it appears that University of Texas quarterback Arch Manning could be leaving tens of millions of dollars on the table due to his conservative approach to the NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) landscape. The potential financial sacrifice, combined with growing criticism from inside the locker room, has opened up a discussion about the Longhorns’ evolving NIL strategy—and whether it’s holding their top athletes back.
This discussion erupted after an unnamed Texas star player, believed to be a prominent starter on the team, told a regional sports outlet that the Longhorns have been “naive” in their handling of NIL opportunities. While the player didn’t directly criticize Arch Manning, his comments made it clear that even within the program, there are growing frustrations about how NIL deals are—or aren’t—being utilized to reward and retain top talent.
### The NIL Gold Rush That Passed Arch Manning By
Arch Manning, the scion of football royalty and arguably the most high-profile college football recruit in over a decade, entered the NCAA scene with unprecedented fanfare. The nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning and grandson of Archie Manning, Arch was expected not only to deliver wins on the field but also to become the face of the NIL era.
Yet, to the surprise of many, Manning has reportedly turned down several multimillion-dollar endorsements and sponsorship opportunities. While other top quarterbacks have inked deals with major brands, car companies, and sportswear giants, Arch has stayed relatively quiet—by choice.
Sources close to the Manning family have consistently said Arch is focused on football first. They believe the NIL opportunities will be there when he’s ready, and that his legacy will be built on the field, not in advertising campaigns.
“He’s not chasing the money right now,” said a family representative last year. “He wants to learn, grow, and prove himself on the field before cashing in.”
But with some NIL deals now exceeding $10 million in total value over multiple years, questions are being asked: is Arch Manning missing his moment? And is the Texas program itself holding players back from reaching their full financial potential?
### Teammate Speaks Out: “We’re Behind the Curve”
The internal tension at Texas exploded into the public sphere this week when a star teammate—speaking on condition of anonymity—criticized the program’s approach to NIL deals.
“We’re behind the curve,” the player said. “Programs like USC, Georgia, LSU—they’re building NIL empires. Meanwhile, we’re playing catch-up. Some of our guys are getting offers from outside collectives and sponsors that never get followed up on. It’s like we don’t even realize what’s possible.”
The same player didn’t mention Arch Manning by name but alluded to the “face of the program” turning down multiple seven-figure offers, calling it “his choice” but a reflection of the program’s “old-school mentality.”
Several boosters have echoed the sentiment in private discussions, noting that while Texas has one of the richest athletic departments in the country, its NIL execution has been inconsistent. The Longhorns have had high-profile deals through their Texas One Fund and partnerships with local businesses, but there’s a growing sense that they could be doing more—especially with someone of Manning’s stature on the roster.
### Arch’s Quiet Commitment
Despite the noise, Arch Manning remains publicly committed to Texas and its process. After taking over the starting job late last season and showing flashes of brilliance, he has established himself as the cornerstone of the Longhorns’ future.
In a recent interview, Manning downplayed NIL talk altogether: “It’s a privilege to play here. I came to Texas to win games and be part of something special. That’s where my focus is.”
Sources close to the team say that Manning has still accepted limited NIL deals—mostly local and charity-based partnerships—but has stayed away from major endorsements, reportedly turning down a $5 million offer from a national fast-food brand and a tech company’s $8 million marketing package.
“It’s not that Arch doesn’t understand his worth,” said a UT staffer. “It’s that he’s choosing a different path—for now.”
### The Bigger Picture: What Does It Mean for Texas?
Manning’s low-key NIL presence, while admirable to some, has triggered a larger conversation about Texas’s competitiveness in the modern era. With powerhouse programs using NIL as a recruitment and retention tool, the Longhorns risk falling behind unless they adapt quickly.
“I love Arch’s integrity, but let’s be real,” said one former Longhorn turned analyst. “This is 2025. NIL is part of the game. If your top guy isn’t embracing it—and your program isn’t pushing it—you’re playing with one hand tied behind your back.”
The criticism has prompted rumblings that the university may soon reevaluate its NIL infrastructure. Several boosters have reportedly begun talks to restructure the Texas One Fund and bring in professional marketing advisors to help athletes make the most of their platforms.
### A Defining Offseason for Arch and the Longhorns
As spring practice wraps and the countdown to the 2025 season begins, Arch Manning finds himself at the center of not just football strategy, but a philosophical debate about the direction of college athletics.
Should athletes, even those from famous families, be encouraged to capitalize on every dollar available? Or is it possible—and even admirable—to resist the commercial side of college football in favor of legacy and development?
For Arch Manning, the answer may remain personal. But for Texas, the answer may decide whether the Longhorns remain contenders—or watch their best players take their talents, and brands, elsewhere.
Please share.
Leave a Reply